Hard to Leave a Gaslighting Relationship? It’s the Good Days
Hard to Leave a Gaslighting Relationship? It's the Good Days
More than twenty-five years out of the service, one memory still sits heavy. I trusted a senior soldier's word and followed an order I now recognize, without any doubt, as wrong.
He put it simply. "This is what's right for the company. For the battalion. For the guys standing next to you."
At the time, that sounded bigger than my own judgment. Bigger than any hesitation I had. So I set the hesitation aside and did what I was told.
It took years to understand something obvious. An order framed as good for everyone is not the same thing as an order that is actually right. What I did was reckless, and the regret never fully left.
I still ask myself why I stopped trusting my own read on that day. When does someone else's certainty start to outweigh your own judgment? And once you know something is wrong, why is it still so hard to walk away from the person, or the structure, holding you there?
Where the Word "Gaslighting" Comes From
The term goes back to Gas Light, a 1938 stage play. In it, a husband dims the gas lamps in the house. When his wife points out that the room is getting darker, he tells her it isn't.
It's a small trick, but it puts her in an awful spot. She can see the flame shrinking, and her own husband is telling her she's wrong. The National Domestic Violence Hotline describes his goal as driving her crazy, and it draws a lesson for real relationships, too. Once a person's trust in what they see and remember has been worn down, they're more likely to stay.
That's one answer to why people stay, and it's a reasonable one. But when the psychoanalyst Robin Stern walks through how gaslighting develops, her first example starts somewhere nicer, with a good dinner.
The Three Stages of Gaslighting, According to Robin Stern
Stern, who wrote The Gaslight Effect, tells this one on her website, calling the pair Rhonda and Dean. On their second date, right after a terrific dinner, Dean left Rhonda alone at a bus stop. He said she was "nuts" for waiting on a bus and went off to catch the subway. When he called that night, it was to insist he'd done nothing wrong. The problem, he told her, was the way she chose to get around. Stern uses it to illustrate her first stage, disbelief.
Rhonda argued with him, but in the end she decided it was just "really weird." She was still up for another date. They had a lot in common, she said, and he was romantic. Stern calls it a red flag and doubts it'll be a one-time thing. Her guess is that Rhonda will keep making excuses for him, at least for a while.
I don't think fear is what keeps Rhonda interested at this point. If anything, it's the dinner, and everything else she likes about him. She can shrug off the bus stop because the rest of the date went so well.
Stern's second stage is defense, where you end up arguing your own case. Her example this time is a boss. You ask him why you keep getting passed over for the good assignments, and instead of answering, he says you're too sensitive and too stressed. So you push yourself even harder on the boring work, just to prove him wrong.
The third stage is depression. By then, she writes, you barely recognize yourself, and there isn't much joy left. She's careful to add that the stages don't always come in order and can overlap. Still, the way I read them, they all point the same way. Little by little, the other person becomes the one who decides what really happened.
The story I told at the start isn't about gaslighting, and I don't want to blur the two. Nobody tried to rewrite what I remembered. The pressure came from rank. What they do share is narrower. It's the point where another person's certainty begins to count for more than your own judgment. For me, that took a single appeal to the greater good. In Stern's stages, it happens slowly.
Because it's so gradual, you can feel it before you have a word for it. One of the warning signs on her list is the sense that something is badly wrong, even though you can't say what. So if the cruelty is out in the open and the self-doubt hurts, why do people stay?
Why Unpredictable Kindness Is So Hard to Quit
Vending machines make this easier to see. Say your office has two. One has never let you down, and the other works maybe half the time. Then one day both break for good. You'd probably give up on the first one right away, since it's hard to miss when a machine that always worked goes dead. The other one you might keep feeding for a while. It's eaten your money before and then come through.
Psychologists who study learning call this the partial, or intermittent, reinforcement effect, and it's been tested for more than 75 years in hundreds of experiments. The basic finding is that a behavior that gets rewarded every time tends to die out fairly fast once the rewards stop, while one rewarded only some of the time usually hangs on longer.
Look at a relationship that way, and the cruelty isn't the only thing that needs explaining. The kindness does too. A good day after a run of bad ones can feel like the candy bar finally dropping.
The easy comparison here is a slot machine, and I think it's only half right. A slot machine is built to do one thing, which is keep you pulling the lever. A relationship has a lot more going on. There's love and shared history, and there may be money, a shared place to live, children, and sometimes real danger in leaving. If we just call someone "addicted" to a partner, we skip past all of that.
So the timing of rewards matters, but it's not the whole story. It helps explain why hope is hard to switch off, but it says nothing about power, or about who gets to decide when the good days come. Two psychologists set out to measure both.
What Trauma Bonding Looks Like After You Leave
From the outside, leaving seems like the end of it. Donald Dutton and Susan Painter looked at what happens afterward.
Back in 1981, the two proposed a theory they named traumatic bonding. Today it often goes by trauma bonding. The theory says that when one person holds far more power, and the treatment keeps swinging between bad and good, the result can be an unusually strong attachment.
In 1993 they published a test of it. They interviewed and surveyed 75 women not long after each had left an abusive partner, then checked in again six months later. Physical violence had happened in fifty of those relationships.
The two strongest predictors of that lingering attachment were how on-and-off the abuse had been and how the balance of power shifted. Together with the overall amount of abuse, those relationship factors accounted for 55 percent of the variation in attachment at six months.
I should be honest about the limits here. Seventy-five people would fit in one lecture hall, so this is a small sample. The study looked at abusive relationships in general, not gaslighting specifically, and it found an association, which isn't the same as proving cause. Even so, for these women, walking out was closer to the middle of the story than the end.
You could argue that practical ties keep that pull alive after someone leaves, like joint bank accounts or kids. But the doctors and the dentist from the start of this post don't fit that explanation as neatly.
Why They Still Wanted to Go Back
These women had their own money, and many hadn't even lived with the men while they were together. Three of them went as far as moving to another city. They still felt the pull.
Mags Lesiak, a Cambridge criminologist, recruited women like these on purpose for a study she wrote with Loraine Gelsthorpe. She wanted to get past the usual explanations for why women stay or go back, like fear of being hurt, or being tied to the man through a home, children, or money.
The women's stories followed a similar pattern. Early on, the men were charming and often intensely devoted. Then the cruelty started. It began with words, and in many cases it turned physical months later. And it came at random, in between stretches when the warmth returned.
There's one more detail that I think changes how the kindness looks. Every woman in the study reported some kind of childhood trauma. In their accounts, the men talked about their own painful childhoods while the affection was still intense, and got the women to open up about theirs. Later, what the women had shared was used against them. Sometimes the point was to fake a sense of closeness. Other times it was to humiliate them, by putting them down over who'd had it worse or by mocking them in front of other people.
Lesiak puts it this way: "Abusers make sure their partners experience euphoric highs and desperate lows." That, she says, creates a reward system that works "on the same logic as a slot machine, with unpredictable wins, sudden losses, and escalating self-blame."
So the slot machine is back, and this time it seems to fit better, since these women weren't financially dependent and many didn't live with their partners. It also reminds you that somebody designed the machine. The study argues that the way trauma bonding is usually explained gives too little weight to what the abuser does to create the attachment. Read that way, the bond says less about the person caught in it and more about what the other person did to build it.
Eighteen interviews can't tell us how common this is. And like the 1993 study, this one covered abuse broadly rather than gaslighting alone. Still, the Hotline's list of emotional abuse warning signs points in the same direction. It includes a partner who goes cold to punish you, and one who showers you with praise and presents, then later uses all that generosity as leverage.
Which takes me back to the play. The lamp in Gas Light never dims by itself. The husband is dimming it on purpose.
Why I Wrote This Down
I'm not a psychologist. I'm just someone who has lived a little longer than some of the people reading this, and none of this is meant to diagnose anyone or hand down a verdict on any relationship.
What I hope, mostly, is that someone younger reading this won't end up carrying the same long regret I have: the one that sounds like, why didn't I trust my own judgment back then.
I turn the question on myself too. Am I doing to another person what that senior soldier did to me? Am I the one saying "it's for you" or "it's for all of us," and using it to talk past someone's hesitation?
The lesson from that old regret is a simple one. A good cause doesn't automatically make a wrong action right. When someone else's certainty starts to crowd out your own doubt, you're allowed to pause. You're allowed to question it. You're allowed to say no. You're allowed to ask for help.
That's the reason I wrote this down. Before someone loses their own judgment inside another person's words, and before I become the person doing the taking, I wanted to push back against that regret, even a little.
Frequently asked questions
What are common signs of gaslighting?
The National Domestic Violence Hotline has a list of signs that it credits to author and psychoanalyst Robin Stern. They include doubting yourself all the time, asking yourself "Am I too sensitive?" multiple times a day, apologizing constantly, covering for your partner with friends and family, struggling with small decisions, and feeling like you used to be someone else entirely.
Does gaslighting only happen in romantic relationships?
No. Robin Stern describes the pattern showing up with a partner, but also with a boss, a friend, or a family member. In her own practice, she writes, it appeared most often in romantic relationships, and she has also worked with both men and women gaslighted at work.
How is gaslighting different from two people remembering something differently?
People often remember the same event differently, and one disagreement isn't gaslighting. The National Domestic Violence Hotline's examples describe something narrower and repeated, like a partner who keeps telling you that you've remembered things wrong when you haven't, or that events you know took place never happened. Over time, the Hotline notes, that pattern can leave a person confused, anxious, and isolated.
Where can someone in the US find help for this?
The National Domestic Violence Hotline is free, confidential, and available 24/7. Call 1-800-799-7233, send the word START by text to 88788, or chat at thehotline.org. Its advocates offer support and safety planning, and the Hotline invites people who are still questioning what's happening in their relationship to reach out. In an emergency, call 911.
Sources & References
- National Domestic Violence Hotline, "What Is Gaslighting?"
- National Domestic Violence Hotline, "What Is Emotional Abuse?"
- National Domestic Violence Hotline, "A Deeper Look Into Gaslighting"
- Robin Stern, "Are You Being Gaslighted? What Are the Stages?"
- Robin Stern, "How to Identify the Gaslight Effect"
- Mellgren, R. L. (2012). "Partial Reinforcement Effect." In N. M. Seel (Ed.), Encyclopedia of the Sciences of Learning. Springer. Springer Link entry
- Dutton, D. G., & Painter, S. L. (1981). "Traumatic Bonding: The Development of Emotional Attachments in Battered Women and Other Relationships of Intermittent Abuse." Victimology: An International Journal, 6, 139–155. Bibliographic record (Uppsala University, in Swedish)
- Dutton, D. G., & Painter, S. (1993). "Emotional Attachments in Abusive Relationships: A Test of Traumatic Bonding Theory." Violence and Victims, 8(2), 105–120. NCJRS abstract · Publisher abstract
- Lesiak, M., & Gelsthorpe, L. (2026). "The Invisible Abuser: Attachment, Victimization, and Perpetrator Perception in Repeat Abuse." Violence Against Women, 32(11), 4195–4214. First published online October 2025. https://doi.org/10.1177/10778012251379423
- University of Cambridge, "Study shows how domestic abusers build 'trauma bonds' with victims before violence begins" (October 15, 2025)
Comments
Post a Comment